link to bibliography sitemap link to bibliography bibliography link to Mnemosyne home mnemosyne home
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
drowning in data
the internet is rhizomatic
navigational conventions & the Internet
early solutions: search engines
the links effect
visualizing the datasphere
spatial metaphors
digital cities and electric suburbias

early solutions: search engines and indexes

It was quickly recognised that users need assistance to access the plethora of websites, news groups, bulletin boards, ftp sites etc. available on the Internet. There has been a continuous effort to provide visual aids to understanding the nature of the Net itself.

Early solutions to the problem of information location, such as search applications (GOPHER, Archie, Veronica etc), bookmarks and link indexes etc, were soon overwhelmed by the sheer exponential growth of available material and users' demands for more efficient and customisable solutions.

Theorists, practitioners, technologists and entrepreneurs have instigated improvements on old systems and suggested new solutions. Improvements to search engine functionality, for example, have been continuous. Unfortunately even the best of these, such as Google, inevitable lag behind the growth of available content and all require specialised knowledge to use effectively. They too often seem incapable of finding things that you know are there... or of helping users to distinguish which sites are likeliest to be what they're looking for. Whilst all search engines rank their findings, there is no commonality in the criteria upon which they do so. Some rank by order of greatest number of correspondences between search terms and metatags or the appearance of the terms in the site text, others on the basis of payment, whilst others rank on number of other sites that link to the found sites.

 

 

 

asterisk graphic Go to Google

link to KartOO large format

A detail from a KartOO search.
click to open new window with large scale version of the image

One intriguing example, KartOO, billed as a meta-search engine, stands out both by virtue of its graphic presentation and the method by which found-site relationships are highlighted. KartOO is the result of three years of research carried out by team headed by Laurent Baleydier. Their research focused on the optimization of systems that collect, analyze, organize and release structured and unstructured data as well as on graphic interfaces and their ergonomics. The resulting cartographic interface presents found sites as 'islands', ranked according to their relevance to the query, varying in size depending on the size of the corresponding site. Links between sites are expressed as lines connecting sites. Related terms drawn from the presented sites scatter the field. When the user mouses over them, the sites that contain them pulse.

asterisk graphic Go to KartOO
 

The start screen for PubMed,the National Library of Medicine's database.
click to open new window with large scale version of the image
asterisk graphic View a 3 minute Quicktime tour of Visual Net

 

 

Link to Visual Map 3D large format view

A detail from a 3D view.
click to open new window with large scale version of the image

Visual Net creates a map of Internet sites by subject, and allows users to either search in a 2D or 3D interface. In either interface, proximity denotes the relationship between subjects. In the 2D view, an architectural metaphor sees each subject area denoted as a room, size indicating the volume of resources available for any subject area. In the 3D view, sites are represented as building, with size and height denoting the volume and popularity of the site. Related sites are shown in neighborhoods, allowing fast navigation to the desired information In both views users can leave visual landmarks to allow them to return quickly to neighborhoods of interest. Customisable icons represent the age, popularity and link density of sites.

asterisk graphic Go to Visual Net

 

Successful user interface metaphors tap into a reservoir of bodily feeling on the part of the user and successfully exploit our embodied knowledge. The problem of disembodied users is that we ordinarily think of user interface design as if the users were disembodied minds when they are not.

Tim Rohrer, Metaphors We Compute By: Bringing magic into interface design'

A project which has looked beyond the more or less disembodied 'point and click' interface is German-based ART+ COM's Terra-Vision (T-Vision). Harking back to the ground breaking work produced by Ray and Charles Eames through the 50s and 60s, and in particular their animated film 'The Power of Ten', T-Vision is designed around a more corporeal user interface and a panoptic point of view.

Founded in 1988, ART+COM is an interdisciplinary group concerned with the integration of computer technology, communication and design. It brings together specialists from the arts, science and the IT industry. T-Vision is essentially an interface to information available over the Internet through an earth visualisation interface.

T-Vision's specific concept of seamless links between different levels of detail allows the continuous zooming from a global view down to recognisable features of only a few centimeters in size. On the virtual globe any kind of geographically related data can be visually incorporated (e.g. biological, sociological, economic etc). It demonstrates coordinated global data retrieval in a way that the WWW only hints at. The user rolls a beach-ball sized trackball, and a globe of the world presented on the screen, rolls correspondingly. The image is made up of a patchwork of satellite and aerial photos. The user can zoom from the macro space view of the world down to individual streets and locations - in fact one can zoom into the Art+Com office, and look through a video camera pointing out the window, and see real-time video action.

T-Vision can utilise the entire Internet, drawing on dispersed databases for its images, so that the globe is continually updated. Because of the impossibility of locally storing and constantly updating all the high resolution data necessary for such visualisation application the T-Vision project is based on the concept of a transparent and worldwide ATM-broadband networked data bank. By approaching a geographical region the system automatically establishes an ATM connection to the server which provides the most up-to-date and highest resolution data required for the current field of view. This data is integrated 'on the fly' in the users system.

asterisk graphic

Go to Terra-Vision

Go to ART+COM

 

Images from a session using T-Vision
asterisk graphic

Many sites include a site search engine. Whilst such facilities seem an obvious service to users, they have proven to more often alienate than aid. Studies conducted by usability experts have shown that using site search leads users to information of interest less frequently than links. Well-considered links lead users to grouped related content.

 

For more about organising information, see:
order and expression

asterisk graphic For a complete(ish) listing of search engines, bots, spiders etc, see: Niemer's Search Tools Page'


Most "search" boxes are not full-text search -- they actually only search the "keyword index" page, which is not itself shown. The Keyword list is built by automated guesswork and looking for defined keywords, which no one uses. No wonder the Search engines so often return no results. The web standards for retrieval paths are very poor, almost nonexistent, compared to the traditional ToC and Index.
Michael Hoffman, Enabling Extremely Rapid Navigation in Your Web or Document

<< home ] [ shiralee saul 2002

Next
The Links Effect